After the Midterms, Most Americans Still Want Most Illegal Aliens Sent Home, New Poll Finds
A post-election Economist/YouGov poll finds 51% want all or most illegal aliens deported. Just 7% want everyone to stay, and 92% want the criminals out at the very least.

Two weeks after the midterms, a lot of people in Washington are telling themselves the country soured on deportations. The country’s own answer, in a poll taken right after the votes were counted, says otherwise.
The Economist/YouGov poll surveyed 1,628 U.S. citizens from Nov. 13 to 16 and asked them a plain question about immigrants who came here illegally: what comes closest to your view? Twenty-three percent said all of them should be deported immediately. Another 28% said most should be deported, with exceptions for people married to Americans or who have lived here many years with no criminal record. Put those together and 51% of Americans want all or most illegal aliens sent home.
Only 7% said everyone here illegally should be allowed to stay. That is the open-borders position in its purest form, and it polls at single digits.

The middle still wants removals
The biggest single group, 41%, picked the answer that says only those who have committed serious crimes should be deported while the others remain. Even that answer is a vote for deportation. It just draws the line at criminals.
Add every answer that sends somebody home and you get 92%: the 23%, the 28% and the 41%. Nine in ten Americans agree that illegal aliens who commit serious crimes should be removed. That is about as close to a consensus as American politics gets, and it is the floor of the debate, not the ceiling.
The real argument is between the 51% who want broad removals and the 41% who want removals focused on criminals. Both camps want enforcement. The sanctuary-city crowd that fights ICE detainers on accused criminals is fighting the 92%, not just the Republicans.
The poll’s margin of error is plus or minus 2.9 points. A 51% majority sits just above the line where it could be a coin flip in either direction, and honest readers should know that. The 92% is not close to that line.
Legal immigration splits the other way
The same poll asked about legal immigration, and the answers show Americans are not anti-immigrant. They are pro-rules. Twenty percent want the number of legal immigrants admitted each year increased, 31% want it kept the same, 22% want it decreased and 9% want it cut to zero. Another 18% weren’t sure.
So the people who want legal immigration held steady or raised, 51%, are exactly as many as the people who want all or most illegal aliens deported. Plenty of Americans hold both views at once. Come through the front door and you’re welcome. Jump the fence and you go back. That is not extremism. It is the deal most of the country thought it already had.
A mandate that didn’t expire on Election Day
Immigration did not top the list of worries this time. Asked in an open-ended question to name the most important problem facing the country, 25% said inflation and 15% said the economy. Immigration came in at 7%, tied with corruption and waste.
That is not a sign people stopped caring. It is what happens when the border stops being a daily crisis on the evening news. When crossings were flooding in, the border was a daily headline. Now the work has moved inside the country, to the slower job of finding and removing the people who got in.
That job is going at a record pace. ICE’s fiscal year 2026 numbers, released Nov. 12 by the Department of Homeland Security, showed more than 491,000 arrests and 483,200 deportations, up from 442,640 deportations the year before. unga.news broke down those numbers when they came out. The new poll says a majority of the country wants that work to keep going, and nine in ten want it to keep going for criminals at the very least.
What the new Congress should hear
A new Congress takes its seats in January, and fights over ICE will land on its desk early. Every member should read this poll before writing a single bill. Defunding removals, blocking detainers or tying agents’ hands at courthouses would put them on the side of the 7% and against a solid majority of the voters who just elected them.
The smarter politicians in both parties already know this. Fights over how ICE operates, from masks to courthouse arrests to state laws aimed at agents, will keep landing in court. Those fights are about tactics. The poll is about the goal, and on the goal the public has not moved: people who broke the law to get here, and especially those who broke it again once they arrived, should not get to stay.
Washington tends to read every election as a referendum on whatever it already wanted to do. On deportations, the voters left a clearer message than the pundits did. Most of them want most illegal aliens gone, almost all of them want the criminals gone, and barely anyone wants to throw the doors open.
Sources
- The Economist/YouGov — The Economist/YouGov Poll, November 13–16, 2026 (toplines, 1,628 U.S. citizens)
- U.S. Department of Homeland Security — ICE Breaks Records in Fiscal Year 2026, With Most Arrests and Deportations in Agency’s History (Nov. 12, 2026)
- U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement — ICE breaks records in fiscal year 2026, with most arrests and deportations in Agency’s history
- unga.news — ICE Arrested More Illegal Aliens in One Year Than Biden Did in Three. It Deported Nearly as Many. (Nov. 15, 2026)