Hochul Locks In a $12 Toll to Drive Into Manhattan, Keeping It Away From Trump
New York’s governor says the congestion toll will rise from $9 to $12 in 2028 and won’t ask Washington for relief, because Trump would rather kill the toll entirely.

If you drive into lower Manhattan for work, Kathy Hochul just told you what your next raise is going to: the toll booth. The governor confirmed to Spectrum News NY1 this week that the peak congestion toll for a car with E-ZPass will climb from $9 to $12 in 2028, right on schedule. And she said she won’t even ask for a break, because asking would mean dealing with the one man in Washington who wants the toll gone.
“I don’t want to take it to Donald Trump because I think his desire is to abolish it entirely,” Hochul told NY1. “And so, it’d be risky to open this issue up to them.”
Read that again. The governor’s case for keeping the higher toll locked in is that the president might actually lower it. Drivers in Queens, Staten Island, Long Island and New Jersey can decide for themselves whose side that puts her on.
A price that was always set to climb
The toll took effect on Jan. 5, 2025, charging drivers to enter Manhattan at or below 60th Street. Hochul paused the original plan in June 2024, then brought it back after the 2024 election with a lower opening price of $9 instead of $15. That lower number was sold as relief. It was really a phase-in. The MTA’s own toll schedule spells it out: $9 now, $12 in 2028 and $15 in 2031.

Do the math for a regular commuter. Someone who drives in about 250 workdays a year pays roughly $2,250 in congestion tolls at today’s rate, before any tunnel credits. At $12 that becomes about $3,000. At $15 it is about $3,750. That is on top of tunnel and bridge tolls, gas, and Manhattan parking, which nobody would call cheap.
Trucks feel it more. A small truck pays $14.40 at peak today, and a large truck or tour bus pays $21.60, according to the MTA. Those costs don’t vanish. They show up on the price of deliveries, repairs and anything else that has to be hauled into the busiest part of the city. Overnight tolls are 75% lower, and taxis and ride-hail trips get a per-ride charge instead of the daily toll, but the people who must drive in during the day have no such escape.
Why Hochul says her hands are tied
Hochul’s explanation is that the increases were a condition of the federal approval that let the program start in the first place, so changing the schedule could invite a federal challenge. In plain English, she would rather keep the hike than reopen a fight she might lose to an administration that wants to let drivers off the hook.
That fight has a history. In February 2025, Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy moved to pull the federal approval for the toll, and Trump celebrated on Truth Social. The MTA sued to keep charging, a federal judge blocked the move, and the tolls kept running. Trump’s position since then hasn’t changed: the program punishes working people for driving to their jobs.
Hochul, meanwhile, is out touring subway stations and crediting the toll for the repairs. On a visit to the run-down Chambers Street J and Z station, where the MTA is set to award a repair contract this month, she told NY1 she thinks the place is “haunted” and joked that she was “Kathy Hochul: Ghostbuster.” She said the state has “the resources now thanks to congestion pricing.” State law requires the program to produce at least $1 billion for the MTA’s capital plan.
The people who keep paying
There is a real question buried under the jokes. The MTA still faces operating budget deficits, and NY1 reported it is also facing pushback over the teams it uses to fight fare beating. So the system is asking drivers to pay more while it struggles to get every subway rider to pay at all. A commuter from Staten Island with no good train option is subsidizing a turnstile someone else just jumped.
Hochul also said she plans to talk with Trump about other transit priorities and wants to “catch him on a good day.” She added a jab, saying he “hasn’t had a good day in a while.” It is an odd way to ask for help from a president she just admitted she is steering around.
What is clear is where each side stands. Trump wants the toll gone. Hochul wants it to keep rising, and she is keeping the schedule away from Washington so nobody can change it. Drivers who were told the $9 toll was a compromise now know it was the starting price.
Sources
- Spectrum News NY1 — Congestion pricing toll increase remains on track for 2028, Hochul says
- Spectrum News NY1 — Chambers Street station overhaul moves forward with congestion pricing funds
- MTA — About the Congestion Relief Zone toll
- News 12 Long Island — Controversial congestion pricing here to stay as toll increase looms