No Spin. Just The Source.
unga.news

Indiana’s Top Court Let a Republican Take His Senate Seat After a Judge Tried to Block It

A county judge barred Chris Garten from his oath the day before session. The Indiana Supreme Court said the Senate, not a judge, decides, and he was sworn in and elected leader.

By @UngaTheGreat ·
Share on XText
Image: The Indiana State Senate chamber at the Statehouse in Indianapolis. Photo: Charles Edward, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

On Monday afternoon, a county judge in southern Indiana told the man in line to lead the state Senate that he could not take his oath. By Tuesday afternoon, Chris Garten had his hand up, the Indiana Supreme Court had overruled that judge, and his colleagues had elected him Senate president pro tem.

The court did it in one short order, and every justice signed on.

At issue was Senate District 45, which covers all of Clark County and part of Floyd County, across the Ohio River from Louisville. Reported totals show Garten, a Charlestown Republican, with 21,817 votes to 21,520 for Democrat Nick Marshall, a 297-vote margin, according to The Indiana Lawyer.

Bar chart of reported Indiana Senate District 45 totals: Chris Garten 21,817, Nick Marshall 21,520
A 297-vote race. Source: vote tallies reported by The Indiana Lawyer, Nov. 17.

A restraining order on the eve of Organization Day

Democrats went to court over Election Day problems in Jeffersonville, where a ballot scanner malfunction was reported at Jeffersonville High School, the voting site for four precincts. They argue the Clark County Election Board, which Republicans control 2-1, didn’t do enough to review what happened there.

At 3:44 p.m. on Nov. 16, a judge in Clark Circuit Court No. 1 issued an ex parte temporary restraining order, meaning one granted without hearing from the other side. It did three things. It barred the county election board and clerk from certifying the District 45 result. It barred them from sending the certified vote count to the state. And it barred Garten “from presenting himself to take the oath of office as, or to be seated as, the Senator from District 45.”

The timing mattered. The Senate was set to organize, swear in members and elect its officers at 1:30 p.m. the next day. Garten’s lawyers told the Supreme Court that without emergency relief, District 45 would have no senator at all until the lawsuit ran its course.

One line of the state constitution

The justices agreed with him on that point. The order, signed by Chief Justice Loretta Rush with all justices concurring, directed the lower court to vacate the part of the order blocking Garten from being sworn in and seated.

The court’s reasoning came down to a single citation: Article 4, Section 10 of the Indiana Constitution, which recognizes “that the respective houses of the legislature are the sole judges of the results of the elections of their members.” In other words, whether Garten belongs in the Senate is for the Senate to decide, not a county judge.

The order went no further than that. The block on certifying and transmitting the District 45 results stays in place for now. The court took Garten’s other requests under advisement, gave the other side until Dec. 7 to respond, and said the case in the lower court can keep going. A preliminary injunction hearing there was set for Wednesday.

Sworn in, then elected leader

Garten took the oath on the Senate floor Tuesday, administered by Rush, and was then elected president pro tem, the chamber’s top post outside the lieutenant governor’s ceremonial role as Senate president. He had been the Senate’s majority floor leader.

Then he did something the Democrats suing him had asked for. He said he had told his legal team to file for a recount.

“I have never opposed a lawful recount,” Garten told reporters. “In fact I welcome transparency. I welcome accountability and have complete confidence in the outcome in the election. But what happened yesterday went far beyond a normal election challenge.”

He called the bid to keep him out of office “law-fare.” “What we witnessed was an extraordinary attempt to use the judicial system to prevent the people from an entire Senate district from having their elected representative take office,” he said.

Garten said lawmakers should look at whether a judge should ever be able to stop a reported winner from being seated, and he framed it as a rule for both parties. “The next time this happens, the candidate may not be a Republican, it may be a Democrat, the district may be somewhere else, but the constitutional questions will be exactly the same,” he said.

A closer race than he’s used to

District 45 wasn’t supposed to be close. Garten won more than 60% of the vote in each of his previous two general elections, The Indiana Lawyer reported. This year Democrats either won or came close in several Republican-held Indiana districts, after a fight over redrawing the state’s congressional map in the middle of the decade. Garten backed that redraw, which President Trump and Gov. Mike Braun pushed and which failed.

Garten spent much of his first speech as leader on working across the aisle, especially on what things cost. “When you disagree, we can defend our convictions and we can still work together,” he said.

Senate Minority Leader Shelli Yoder, a Bloomington Democrat, said she would let the court case and the recount play out. She also had kind words for the speech. “It was very refreshing to hear the speech that we heard,” she said. “I’m really excited that we’re going to work together.”

For now, the voters of District 45 have a senator. Whether the numbers hold is up to the recount, and if it comes to that, the Senate itself.

ShareShare on XText

Sources

  1. Indiana Supreme Court — State of Indiana ex rel. Chris Garten v. Clark Circuit Court No. 1 (26S-OR-412)
  2. The Indiana Lawyer — New Senate leader calls for recount after Indiana Supreme Court clears way for him to take office
  3. IndyStar — Indiana’s next Senate leader can take oath of office, Supreme Court rules
  4. WISH-TV — Indiana Supreme Court clears way for Chris Garten to take Senate seat
← Back to unga.news