Ruby Franke’s Daughter Begs Utah to Keep Her Mother Locked Up: She ‘Would Have Killed Them’
Shari Franke emailed Utah’s parole board ahead of the Dec. 7 hearings for Ruby Franke and Jodi Hildebrandt. Her ask is simple: deny parole for both.

Shari Franke has done what the system could not do three years ago. She has put it in writing, to the people who hold the keys, that her mother should stay behind bars.
Ruby Franke’s oldest daughter emailed a statement to the Utah Board of Pardons and Parole ahead of the Dec. 7 hearings for her mother and for Jodi Hildebrandt, the counselor who was convicted alongside her. Shari said she can’t be there in person, so she sent the board her words and posted them on Instagram on Monday. Her request is simple: deny parole for both women.
“Ruby would not have stopped what she was doing unless my brother had miraculously saved himself and my sister,” she wrote. “Ruby would have killed them.”
A boy, a window and a neighbor
Most of the country remembers how this case broke open. On Aug. 30, 2023, Franke’s 12-year-old son climbed out of a window at Hildebrandt’s home in Ivins, a small town just outside St. George, and ran to a neighbor’s house asking for food and water. According to the Washington County Attorney’s Office, the neighbor saw duct tape on the boy’s wrists and ankles, severe wounds and malnourishment, and called police. Officers arrested Hildebrandt at the house and found the boy’s younger sister hiding in a closet.
What investigators found next was worse. Prosecutors say the two children were held in a “work-camp like setting,” denied food, water and beds, forced to labor outside in the summer heat without shoes and made to stand on a cement patio for hours and even days. They were beaten. The boy had been bound hand and foot after an earlier attempt to run. The county attorney’s office said the women believed the abuse was needed to make the children “repent” for imagined sins.
Franke pleaded guilty on Dec. 18, 2023, to four counts of aggravated child abuse, a second-degree felony. Hildebrandt pleaded guilty to the same four counts on Dec. 27. On Feb. 20, 2024, Fifth District Judge John Walton sentenced each woman in St. George to four terms of one to 15 years, to be served back to back. Utah caps consecutive sentences at 30 years, so each faces four to 30 years. Walton told Hildebrandt that her philosophy for dealing with the children “frankly seems detached from reality or any objective standard of decency, or even common sense.”

What the board can and can’t do
Here is the part worth understanding before anyone panics. The Dec. 7 hearings are what Utah calls original parole hearings, the first time an inmate goes before the board. Franke is up at 9 a.m. and Hildebrandt at 9:30 a.m., back to back, in the board’s courtroom at the Utah State Correctional Facility. The hearings will be livestreamed on the board’s website.
Utah judges hand down a range, not a fixed term, and the board decides how much of it gets served. In its Oct. 23 announcement, the board said its 2023 guidelines would recommend 40 months for these crimes, which would point to a release date of Dec. 30, 2026. But the judge set a 48-month minimum, and the board said state law, Utah Code 77-27-9, bars it from releasing either woman before that full minimum is served.
So nobody walks out of prison on Dec. 7. What the board does decide is the shape of what comes next. After the hearing, its members vote, and the board can deny parole, grant it or set a future hearing date. Its decision is posted on its website. Victims can speak at the hearing or send written statements beforehand, which is exactly what Shari did.
That matters more than usual here. Franke’s plea deal, according to The Salt Lake Tribune, requires the Washington County Attorney’s Office to “remain neutral” at her future parole hearings. With the prosecutors sitting this one out by agreement, the loudest voice for the children may be the sister who tried to save them.
“I fought for them”
Shari’s statement is not the work of someone chasing headlines. It reads like someone who has carried this for a long time.
“It’s been 4 years since I last talked face to face with Ruby,” she wrote. “For the next year, I was cut off from all my siblings, but I couldn’t shake the feeling that something terrible was happening. I want them to know I fought for them. I called the police, I called CPS, I spoke to lawyers. And Ruby and Jodi evaded all of them.”
At her sentencing, Franke told the court, “I take full accountability for my actions,” according to KSL. Her daughter isn’t buying it. “I will never accept Ruby’s apology for what she has done,” Shari wrote. “She has been a monster her entire adult life, and there’s no way that’s changed in 3 years.”
She said her mother has never answered for how she treated Shari and her brother Chad growing up. “I was forced to watch and listen to her beat my brother Chad mercilessly,” she wrote. “I would slide him tissues under the door for the bloody noses she gave him.” She also wrote that her mother stayed silent with investigators until she learned Hildebrandt had turned on her, and only then began to talk and apologize.
“In her mind, all her problems started and ended with Jodi,” Shari wrote. “Until she realizes that is not the case, and acknowledges she has issues that go way beyond Jodi, I don’t think she can fully heal.”
On Hildebrandt, she was blunter still. “She is not sorry, and she is one of the most dangerous people I know,” Shari wrote, calling her “a master manipulator.” Hildebrandt told the judge in 2024, “I sincerely love these children.” Shari’s answer: “I would personally blame the state of Utah if she were released and did something like this again.”
And then the line that should hang over the hearing room: “For the first time in our lives, my family is happy. We are happy without Ruby.”
Shari, who told her story in her January 2025 memoir, The House of My Mother, said she still has nightmares at least weekly of being trapped in her mother’s home, trying to save her siblings. Forgiveness, she wrote, means living a life where her mother has no hold on her choices. It doesn’t mean opening the prison door.
The board owes these children a sentence that matches what was done to them. Their sister has made her case. It’s now up to the board.
Sources
- KUTV — Shari Franke releases statement ahead of Ruby Franke, Jodi Hildebrandt’s parole hearing (full statement)
- ABC4 Utah — ‘She has been a monster’: Ruby Franke’s daughter releases statement ahead of parole hearing
- Utah Board of Pardons and Parole — Board Sets Original Parole Hearing Dates for Ruby Franke and Jodi Hildebrandt (Oct. 23, 2026) and pool media advisory
- Washington County Attorney’s Office — Utah vs Franke/Hildebrandt
- KSL — ‘8 Passengers’ mom Ruby Franke and Jodi Hildebrandt sentenced for aggravated child abuse
- The Salt Lake Tribune — Ruby Franke, Jodi Hildebrandt sentenced in Utah child abuse case
- Deseret News — Jodi Hildebrandt and Ruby Franke sentenced to 4 consecutive terms in prison