Senate Promotes the Judge Who Backed ICE Detention and Christian Preschools to a Top Western Court
Daniel Domenico won confirmation 51 to 46 to the appeals court over Utah, Colorado and four other states, after standing alone in Colorado for the government’s reading of immigration law.

If you live in Utah, Colorado, Kansas, Oklahoma, New Mexico or Wyoming, the federal court that has the last word on almost every case out of your state just got a new judge, and conservatives have reason to cheer. The Senate on Monday confirmed Judge Daniel D. Domenico to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit by a vote of 51 to 46.
The vote broke along party lines, Bloomberg Law reported. Domenico is the first appeals court nominee the Senate has confirmed since July, and he is the only judge President Trump has sent to the Tenth Circuit in his second term.
A judge who stuck his neck out
The ruling that drew the most fire came this spring. As Colorado’s chief federal judge, he looked at the government’s argument that immigration law lets it hold illegal aliens without a bond hearing, even ones who have been in the country for years. Every other federal judge in Colorado who had taken up the question said no. Domenico said yes.
He didn’t pretend it was easy. “The majority of district courts, including all of the judges in this District who have addressed the issue, have found that detention of noncitizens similar to the petitioner under (the mandatory detention provision) is improper,” he wrote in an April 15 order, according to Colorado Politics. “There are legitimate arguments on both sides.” Then he sided with the government anyway, because that is how he read the statute.
That is what you want from a judge. He showed his work, admitted he was the outlier, and ruled on the text instead of the headcount. When the Tenth Circuit later rejected the government’s reading in a June 30 decision, Domenico followed the higher court and ordered bond hearings or release in the cases in front of him. Read the law, rule, then follow the court above you once it speaks. That is the job.
At his June hearing he defended that record. “Ultimately I think if you look deeper into my record on those immigration cases, you’ll see that I have ruled in favor of petitioners in a number of those cases on separate bases,” he told the Senate Judiciary Committee, Law.com reported.

Churches, preschools and a Catholic clinic
The immigration case was hardly his only big one. As a trial judge, Domenico blocked Colorado from enforcing its ban on “abortion reversal” treatment against a Catholic health clinic. He made the state let a Christian preschool into its universal pre-K program even though the school’s policies clashed with the state’s non-discrimination rules. Early in COVID he exempted two Denver-area churches from some health restrictions, and he let a Castle Rock church get around zoning rules for faith-based reasons.
Put those together and you see a judge who takes religious liberty seriously, even when the state of Colorado doesn’t like the answer. For families in the six states this court covers, that matters. The Tenth Circuit is where fights over public lands, water, gun laws, tribal jurisdiction, school rules and religious freedom usually end, because the Supreme Court takes only a sliver of cases.
Domenico, 54, is a Georgetown and University of Virginia law graduate who clerked for the judge he is replacing, Timothy M. Tymkovich, a George W. Bush appointee who is taking senior status. He later served as Colorado’s solicitor general under Republican Attorney General John Suthers and argued two cases at the U.S. Supreme Court. He wanted this same court back in 2017, when Neil Gorsuch left it for the Supreme Court. Trump put him on the trial bench instead.
The math on the bench
Don’t expect this one confirmation to flip the court. The Tenth Circuit has 12 full-time judges, and Colorado Politics counts seven named by Democratic presidents and five by Republicans. Domenico takes a Republican-appointed seat, so the split stays where it is. What changes is age and energy. A 54-year-old with a lifetime appointment could sit on that court for a generation. He joins Allison H. Eid of Colorado and Joel M. Carson III of New Mexico as Trump’s three picks there across both terms.
Colorado’s two Democratic senators, Michael Bennet and John Hickenlooper, voted no. A Hickenlooper spokesperson said the judge’s “refusal to acknowledge the outcome of the 2020 election and his record on immigration were troubling.” In other words, they opposed him for backing enforcement and for not reciting the answer they wanted on 2020 at a hearing.
Senate Republicans aren’t slowing down. Three more appeals court nominees are still pending, and Anna St. John’s nomination to the Fifth Circuit is expected to get a vote this week. Every lifetime seat filled before January stays filled long after this Congress is gone.
Domenico also leaves behind a trial court that is drowning. Colorado’s federal court is getting roughly 100 detention petitions a week, which has about doubled its caseload in months, and his old seat now needs a nominee too. For the six states under the Tenth Circuit, though, Monday’s vote put a judge on the appeals bench who reads the statute first and isn’t afraid to stand alone when the text tells him to.
Sources
- Colorado Politics — Senate confirms Colorado’s Daniel Domenico to 10th Circuit
- Bloomberg Law — Trump Pick Who Backed Migrant Detention Headed to Appeals Court
- Colorado Politics — Colorado’s chief federal judge breaks with colleagues on issue of mandatory immigration detention
- Law.com — 10th Circuit Nominee Defends Stance on Trump’s Mandatory Immigration Detention Policy
- U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee — Confirmed Nominations
- Office of Sen. John Hickenlooper — Hickenlooper Office Statement on Opposition to Daniel Domenico’s Tenth Circuit Confirmation