No Spin. Just The Source.
unga.news

Senate Republicans Just Locked In a Lifetime Judge for Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi

Judge Anna St. John won confirmation to the Fifth Circuit 52 to 46, seven months after she first took the federal bench in New Orleans.

By @UngaTheGreat ·
Share on XText
Image: The John Minor Wisdom U.S. Court of Appeals Building in New Orleans, home of the Fifth Circuit. Photo via Flickr, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Anna St. John started 2026 as a lawyer. She ends it with a lifetime seat on the federal appeals court that hears cases from Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi.

The Senate confirmed her to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit on Tuesday, 52 to 46, according to the Senate press gallery’s floor log. Every Republican who voted said yes. All 44 Democrats and both independents voted no. Two senators didn’t vote.

For people in those three states, this is one of the most consequential votes the Senate took all week. The Fifth Circuit has 17 seats and sits one step below the Supreme Court. Fights over the border, energy, guns, elections and federal agency power from Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi run through it, and most of its rulings are the last word.

Bar chart of Senate roll call 265 on Anna St. John: 52 yes, all Republicans; 46 no, 44 Democrats and 2 independents; 2 not voting
Confirmed, 52 to 46. Source: U.S. Senate Periodical Press Gallery and roll call vote 265.

From the trial bench to the appeals court in seven months

St. John moved fast. She took her seat as a U.S. district judge in New Orleans on April 23, The Times-Picayune reported. Two months later, President Trump announced he would move her up. “Anna will continue to defend Americans’ Constitutional Rights on the Fifth Circuit,” he wrote on Truth Social in June, Bloomberg Law reported.

The formal nomination came July 14, and she sat alone on the first panel at a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on Aug. 5. Because she had just been vetted for the trial bench, her paperwork and background checks carried over, which sped the process along, according to The Times-Picayune.

She fills the seat of Judge Kurt Engelhardt of New Orleans, who chose to take senior status, the semi-retirement that lets a judge keep hearing cases while opening his seat for a successor.

A Gulfport native who fought bad class-action deals

St. John is 46 and grew up in Gulfport, Mississippi. She graduated near the top of her class at LSU, went on to Columbia Law School and clerked for Fifth Circuit Judge Rhesa Barksdale before joining a multinational firm that handles complex litigation.

Her résumé stands out for what she did next. She became general counsel at the Hamilton Lincoln Law Institute, a conservative public interest group in Washington, where she went after class-action settlements she considered unfair. Those are the deals where lawyers walk away with millions while the people they represent get coupons or a few dollars. She also practiced at a small New Orleans firm.

That record is exactly why Democrats lined up against her. The Times-Picayune noted that most Louisiana judicial picks have been former prosecutors who draw little fire, while St. John’s conservative legal positions drew Democratic opposition. Both of Louisiana’s senators, Republicans Bill Cassidy and John Kennedy, voted for her.

Why the Senate is moving judges now

The timing isn’t an accident. Senate Republicans are pushing as many of the president’s nominees through as they can before the current Congress ends and a new Senate is seated in January. Every judge confirmed in these weeks is a seat locked in for decades, no matter who controls the chamber next year.

Appeals court seats matter most in that math. District judges handle trials. Circuit judges write the rules those trial judges must follow across whole regions of the country. A 46-year-old appellate judge could sit on the Fifth Circuit for 30 years or more.

Conservatives have pressed Senate leaders all fall to keep the confirmation line moving. This vote is the kind of result they’ve been asking for: a young, credentialed judge with a record of fighting for regular class members, confirmed on a clean party-line vote, with Louisiana’s own senators on board.

What it means on the ground

The Fifth Circuit decides cases ordinary people feel directly. It has ruled on Texas border measures, state election laws, federal regulations aimed at oil and gas producers, and gun restrictions. When a federal agency writes a sweeping rule and a business in Houston or Baton Rouge sues, this court often decides whether the rule survives.

St. John now gets a vote on all of it. She’ll hear cases in panels of three, and in the big ones, with the full court. For a judge who built her career challenging deals that shortchanged the people they were supposed to help, the seat comes with a lifetime to keep doing it.

The Senate gaveled back in at 10 a.m. Wednesday with more votes on the docket, including a big permitting bill. More nominees are lined up behind her.

ShareShare on XText

Sources

  1. U.S. Senate Periodical Press Gallery — Tuesday, November 17, 2026
  2. The Times-Picayune | nola.com — Anna St. John wins final Senate approval to join 5th US Circuit Court of Appeals
  3. Bloomberg Law — Trump Announces Plans to Nominate St. John to Fifth Circuit
  4. Senate Judiciary Committee — Nominations hearing, Aug. 5, 2026
← Back to unga.news