Wyoming’s New Republican Governor Picked a Democrat as Top Lawyer. GOP Senators Are Split.
Gov.-elect Eric Barlow’s attorney general pick, energy lawyer Walter Eggers, needs 16 Senate votes in January. Three Republicans already say no.

Wyoming likes to call itself the reddest state in America. Now its incoming Republican governor wants a Democrat to be the state’s top lawyer, and the Republicans who have to sign off on him can’t agree on what to do.
Gov.-elect Eric Barlow last week nominated Cheyenne attorney Walter Eggers, 57, to be Wyoming’s attorney general. Eggers is a lifelong Democrat. He is also a lawyer who spent most of a 29-year career representing the oil, gas, coal and trona companies that keep Wyoming’s economy running.
On Tuesday, Cowboy State Daily reached 15 Republican state senators to ask how they would vote. The answers were all over the map.
Three hard nos
Three senators said flatly they would not confirm him. “I know that I won’t vote to confirm a Democrat,” Sen. Troy McKeown of Gillette told the paper. “I’m floored that (Barlow) did it.” He added: “I think we all run around and say we’re the reddest state in the nation. I’m not sure that’s true anymore.”
Sens. Laura Taliaferro Pearson of Kemmerer and Tim French of Ralston were the other two. “I don’t think he’s going to stand for the conservative principles of Wyoming,” Pearson said. French put it more simply: “I think (the nominee) should be a conservative Republican.”
Sen. Brian Boner of Douglas didn’t rule Eggers out, but said “it doesn’t help that he’s a Democrat.” Boner wants to question him on how he would defend Wyoming’s abortion laws and its school-choice programs. Eggers, he said, would “have to satisfy a pretty robust set of questions, at least from me, in order to earn my vote.”

One firm yes, and a lot of open minds
Sen. Cale Case of Lander said he has worked with Eggers on rewriting Wyoming’s corporate laws and will vote yes. “We used to consider the person more than the party,” Case said, adding that he has gotten “a couple nasty emails” telling him not to.
The biggest group, eight senators, said being a Democrat isn’t an automatic disqualifier and they want to study the nominee before deciding. Incoming Senate Vice President Ed Cooper of Ten Sleep was blunt about it. “Some of these jobs, really, the partisanship really shouldn’t figure into them,” he said. “If he’s the right person for the job, I’m OK with that. If he’s not, my vote will go the other way.”
Sen. Cheri Steinmetz of Torrington said she plans to do “some more investigating” and pointed out that some state boards the Senate confirms actually reserve seats for Democrats. Sen. John Kolb of Rock Springs said he would “actively listen” to Eggers’ vetting interview, and cited former Democratic Attorney General Pat Crank as someone he considers “a pretty conservative, quality person.”
The math
Eggers needs at least 16 yes votes in the 31-member Senate when lawmakers take up his nomination in January. The chamber has 29 Republicans and two Democrats. Assuming both Democrats vote yes, he would still need at least 14 Republicans, and right now only one has publicly committed.
Pressure is already coming from the right. The State Freedom Caucus Network, the national group behind the Wyoming Freedom Caucus, sent out a message Tuesday urging people to call Senate President nominee Tara Nethercott and stop the confirmation. Cooper wasn’t moved. “I don’t think any of us are ready to bow to the will of the Freedom Caucus,” he said. Freedom Caucus-aligned candidates largely lost their races in the Aug. 18 primary, and no public Freedom Caucus members won Senate seats this cycle, according to Cowboy State Daily.
Who is Walter Eggers?
Eggers spent 24 to 25 years at the firm Holland & Hart representing traditional energy companies. Matt Micheli, a former state GOP chairman who worked with him for years, called him “one of the smartest, best lawyers I’ve ever known.” Eggers has also given thousands of dollars to Democratic candidates and causes over the years, including Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama and Joe Biden.
He told Cowboy State Daily last week that he is married to a registered Republican and that he never felt any conflict between his party and his work for the energy industry. “I believe very strongly that those companies are the lifeblood of our state’s economy,” he said.
Three former Wyoming attorneys general told the paper his party shouldn’t matter. Gay Woodhouse, a lifelong Republican who served under GOP Gov. Jim Geringer, said the job is “not about politics. It’s about the law.”
If he is confirmed, one of his first duties would be defending the laws Wyoming’s deep-red Legislature passes when they get challenged in court, including the state’s abortion ban. That is exactly the question Republican senators plan to press him on in January.
Sources
- Cowboy State Daily — Wyoming GOP Senators Give Mixed Reviews On Confirming Democrat As Attorney General
- Cowboy State Daily — Barlow’s Attorney General Is A Democrat. Former Wyoming AGs Say It Doesn’t Matter
- Cowboy State Daily — Gov.-Elect Barlow Nominates Longtime Energy-Sector Lawyer For Attorney General
- Office of the Governor-elect — Governor-elect Eric Barlow Announces Senior Leadership Selections