After 20 Years in Congress, She’s Down 331 Votes. Every Ballot in Her District Gets Counted Again.
North Carolina’s Virginia Foxx asked for a recount in writing Tuesday, and machines started rerunning ballots Wednesday. Here’s how the count works and why both parties are in the room.

Election workers in Watauga County fed the first of just over 24,000 ballots back through the machines Wednesday morning. Every one of them will be counted again because of a single number: 331. That is how many votes separate Rep. Virginia Foxx, the Republican who has held North Carolina’s 5th District since 2005, from Democrat Chuck Hubbard, out of 286,788 cast.
The new piece is the recount itself. When unga.news first looked at this race on Nov. 6, Hubbard led by 99 and thousands of provisional ballots were still out. The county canvass is now finished, the gap has grown to 331, and Foxx has put her request in writing. Watauga County, home to Appalachian State, started counting Wednesday, according to WXII. Most of the other counties start Thursday, and Surry goes Friday.

Her request, in writing
Foxx sent her request to Sam Hayes, the State Board of Elections’ executive director, on Tuesday, the deadline day for House races. It is short and all business. “Following the completion of the canvasses for all counties in CD05, the margin between me and my opponent, Chuck Hubbard, stands at 331 votes, representing less than 1% of the total votes cast in this race,” she wrote. She asked for a recount “throughout all counties” under state supervision, and for the board to tell her lawyers the schedule, the locations and the arrangements for observers.
That last line matters. Foxx is the chairwoman of the House Rules Committee and has been around long enough to know that a recount is only as trustworthy as the people allowed to watch it. Back on Nov. 6, she asked for congressional observers while the provisional ballots were still being sorted. Now her team wants eyes in every room.
North Carolina law is simple on who gets a do-over. For races below the statewide level, the trailing candidate can demand a recount when the gap is no more than 1% of the votes cast. In the 5th District, 1% is 2,868 votes. Hubbard’s lead is about a ninth of that, roughly 0.12%.

How the count works, ballot by ballot
This is not a room full of people squinting at paper, at least not yet. The first round is a machine recount. Bipartisan teams of two run every ballot in the race back through the tabulators. Anything a machine kicks out goes to a four-person bipartisan team to count by hand, and at least three county board members, including a Republican and a Democrat, rule on any ballot where the voter’s intent is in doubt, according to the State Board’s process as laid out by Edit USA.
If the machines don’t change the outcome, the trailing candidate gets 24 hours to ask for a hand count of a random 3% of precincts and early voting sites. If that sample shows enough movement to flip the race when projected across the district, the board orders a full hand recount. The machine counts are expected to wrap by Nov. 23, and the State Board plans to meet Nov. 24 to certify.
Hubbard sounds confident. “We certainly are willing to go through the process as laid out by law, and that won’t really change anything,” he told NC Newsline. Maybe so. Recounts usually move a few votes, not a few hundred. Adam Newmark, a political scientist at Appalachian State, told the same outlet the machines might catch “two ballots got stuck together or something, little things like that.”
But the whole point of a recount is that nobody gets to decide the answer in advance. Hubbard’s lead runs through two counties. He won Guilford, the district’s biggest, by about 47,900 votes, and Watauga by about 6,700. Foxx carried the other eight. Guilford alone expects its recount to take two to three days.
Two other recounts, one of them going the other way
Foxx’s race isn’t the only one getting a second look. Down the road in the 10th District, it’s the Democrat asking for the recount. Ashley Bell trails Republican Rep. Pat Harrigan by 2,509 votes, about 0.85%, just inside the 1% line. Five counties are recounting. In Catawba County, a bipartisan team started feeding ballots through two machines at 8:30 Wednesday morning, with the county GOP chairman watching and planning to stay until the last ballot, WBTV reported. Harrigan has declared victory but said he respects Bell’s right to ask.
In southern Minnesota, Rep. Brad Finstad trails Democrat Jake Johnson by 323 votes in the 1st District. Minnesota pays for a recount when the margin is within a quarter of a percent. The state canvassing board meets Thursday to certify, Finstad has until 5 p.m. Monday to make it official, and a hand count across all 21 counties would start the week of Nov. 30, according to KLGR. unga.news covered Finstad’s call the week of the election.
Counted in the open
For all the talk about election integrity, this is what it looks like when the system does its job. Paper ballots exist. Both parties sit at the table. The public can walk in and watch. North Carolina bars anyone from photographing a voted ballot, but it doesn’t bar anyone from standing there while it’s counted.
Foxx isn’t pretending this is easy. She has already told supporters she plans to file for 2028, no matter how the recount ends. “Regardless of the outcome of this race, I’m not going away,” she said, according to NC Newsline. “It’s going to be the toughest fight of my life.”
After more than two decades in Congress, she has earned the right to make the state count every one of those 286,788 votes twice. If 331 holds, it holds. If it doesn’t, the ballots will say so, in a room anyone can walk into.
Sources
- N.C. State Board of Elections — Virginia Foxx recount request, 5th Congressional District (Nov. 17, 2026)
- WXII — Watauga County recount underway as Virginia Foxx trails Chuck Hubbard by 331 votes
- WBTV — Catawba County recounts ballots in tight 10th Congressional District race
- NC Newsline — NC Republicans eye 2028 comeback as two US House races move to recount
- Edit USA — North Carolina recounts two U.S. House races as Virginia Foxx trails by 331 votes
- KLGR — 1st District Recount
- North Carolina General Assembly — G.S. 163-182.7: Ordering recounts
- unga.news — Foxx Won 8 Counties. Guilford and Watauga Still Have Her Down by 99.